Jodi Arias: Hell Hath No Fury

Arias prosecutor scrutinized for intense approach

PHOENIX (AP) – Known as a bulldog with a pedal-to-the-metal approach to prosecuting cases, Deputy Maricopa County Attorney Juan Martinez no doubt stumped Jodi Arias repeatedly throughout his intense cross-examination in her murder trial.

He raised his voice and acted out scenarios in dramatic fashion. He snapped as she dodged questions, cutting her off mid-sentence. Arias held her own periodically, appearing to smugly toy with Martinez as she smirked and repeatedly answered yes or no questions with “sure” and “I guess.”

The exchanges rattled the seasoned prosecutor as the case at times devolved into a showdown of wit and will. The judge had to admonish both to stop speaking over each other.

“I think I’m more focused on your posture and your tone and your anger so it’s hard to process the questions,” Arias told Martinez.

The exchanges came during a pivotal week of testimony in the case and raised questions among the thousands of trial watchers around the world about whether the prosecutor’s ferocious approach helped or hurt his chances of landing a first-degree murder conviction and securing a death sentence.

Some experts say the approach could undermine the prosecution’s case, diverting attention from the brutal attack and putting the spotlight on him. Others compliment his tenacity as a no-nonsense tactic aimed at stumping Arias and getting her off script after having several years in jail to rehearse her testimony.

As Martinez noted in his January opening statements, this case isn’t a whodunit. Arias admits to having killed her lover in his suburban Phoenix home in June 2008, she says, in self-defense. Authorities say she planned the attack on Travis Alexander in a jealous rage, then repeatedly lied to friends, family and police to cover her tracks and avoid suspicion. Arias admits to the latter, too, noting she was too ashamed and scared to tell the truth, first denying having anything to do with it, then blaming it on masked intruders before settling on self-defense.

It’s a prosecutor’s dream case largely based on Arias’ own actions and repeated lies. She dumped the gun in the desert, got rid of her bloody clothes, tried to clean the scene at Alexander’s home and even left the victim a voicemail on his mobile phone within hours of killing him and dragging his body into the shower.

And while most observers agree she will likely be convicted of first-degree murder – at the very least the lesser second-degree – some say it will be due to Arias’ own missteps, not Martinez’s prowess as a prosecutor.

“And if the jury comes back with death, it won’t be because of Juan Martinez. It will be in spite of him,” said Phoenix defense attorney Mel McDonald, a former Maricopa County judge and federal prosecutor.

McDonald, who has seen Martinez in action for years, said his style has always been combative.

“You can be mad, but to be mad all the time is strategically not well-reasoned,” McDonald continued.

Of Martinez’s performance on cross-examination last week, he said, “It was like two people having an argument, and when that happens, it takes the focus away from Jodi Arias and this absolutely grotesque human act of sheer brutality where it belongs.”

Alexander had been stabbed and slashed 27 times, had his throat slit and was shot in the forehead.

McDonald noted Martinez’s style “makes for great television, nice theatrics, but for effective litigation, it simply isn’t the way to do it.”

The trial has captured headlines nationwide for weeks with salacious tales of raunchy sex, betrayal and a bloody killing, and is likely one of the most high-profile cases ever handled by Martinez, who has been a county prosecutor here for 25 years, the last 17 solely focused on defendants charged with murder. He has declined to comment during the trial.

California criminal defense attorney Michael Cardoza, who has been following the case, said that while Martinez’s approach may have turned off some jurors who see a fragile woman on the witness stand, regardless of the heinous nature of the killing, his toned-down style on his final day of questioning Arias on Thursday sealed the deal.

“That was the best day he had. That was the case for him, that was absolutely the case,” Cardoza said.

Cardoza also noted that Martinez may have been aggressive by design to wear down her preparedness and catch her off-guard.

“When the defendant gets in trouble is when they get comfortable, and that’s when you know you’ve got them, that’s when you start peppering them,” he said. “They think they’re smarter than you.”

As defense attorneys question Arias again on Monday, Cardoza said their main goal will be to “blunt the sting” of the cross-examination, during which she admitted to lying repeatedly trying not to get caught.

As she described her efforts to avoid suspicion, Arias buried her face in her hands and sobbed. Martinez continued to press her. He later turned to the judge and simply said “I don’t have anything else,” then unassumingly returned to his chair.

Source: AP

Copyright 2013 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Share this post!
Facebook Twitter Linkedin Email Pinterest


jalfratielf says:

Hello! I just would like to give a huge thumbs up for the wonderful info you might have here on this post. I will be coming back to your blog for much more soon.

christian louboutin shoes

tiZecrilt says:

An impressive share, I just given this onto a colleague who was performing a little analysis on this. And he in actual fact bought me breakfast due to the fact I identified it for him.. smile. So let me reword that: Thnx for the treat! But yeah Thnkx for spending the time to talk about this, I feel strongly about it and love reading a lot more on this subject. If feasible, as you become expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more details? It’s extremely valuable for me. Large thumb up for this weblog post!

red bottom sandals

tiZecrilt says:

It is hard to get knowledgeable consumers on this subject, but you sound like you know what you are talking about! Thanks

michael kors bags sale

KiliaExilalot says:

You will find some interesting points in time in this article but I don’t know if I see all of them center to heart. There is certainly some validity but I will take hold opinion until I look into it further. Beneficial post , thanks and we want even more! Added to FeedBurner as well

michael kors bags cheap

sandra stephens says:

In reference to the Jodi Arias Case. .
I have the same closet system as Travis Alexander and you may already know this information. I have not heard it’s construction issues be mentioned though. Therefore, I am compelled to write you from my personal experience.
Travis had what we call a peg system closet. Meaning the little metal pegs stick in the holes along the side in order to move the shelves up and down. The shelves themselves only suspend on the top of these small metal pegs and the shelf is not “held” into place by anything except gravity. If one was to step on the front edge the back would flip up dumping the contents of the shelf/s onto the floor.
In addition, the shelves are made of particle board not solid wood. They are only made to look like wood with a thin layer of wood laminate over particle board. I weigh 133lbs. I stepped on a lower shelf of my closet system that’s exactly like Travis’s. I was attempting to hoist myself to the top shelf for sheets. Not only did the back of the shelf flip up but it also broke down the middle and dumped the contents of the shelf and myself onto the floor. It is not possible for her to put her weight on those shelves without the back flipping up and/or breaking the shelf in two pieces where my toes were placed.

Madea3 says:

Oh! by the way, God forbbid, if I had to save my life from a crazy man and kill him I wouldn’t be ashamed, heck no, I would stand up for myself and remember everything.

Madea3 says:

Thanks addicted, I’m addicted too, I do not tolerate lying whatsoever.

Madea3 says:

This girl is rotten to the core and Martinez knows that, I felt angry too with her nonsense and he made me happy when he jumped on her s**t. She is smug and Nurmi will kiss the booboos and make them go away. I don’t think so. The jury has had the weekend to ponder. They have got to know by now this memory loss is a copout and they have got to be sick of it. The jury is dreading tomorrow… slow questions and long, long, long percise bable. I am bracing myself for an aggravating day with Jodibalony. It must be nice to have a lover, 3 meals a day, library, TV, Art and whatever we all pay for. He sweetheart will be out soon, Jodi will replace her with another lover. The last thing I would have on my mind is sex if I were up for the death penalty.

addictedtoariastrial says:

well….maam, I agree


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *